Skip to main content

Get the Reddit app

Scan this QR code to download the app now
Or check it out in the app stores
r/Animals icon
r/Animals icon
Go to Animals
r/Animals
A banner for the subreddit

The best ANIMALS community anywhere. Photos, videos, news, stories and discussions about animals & wildlife.


Members Online

Thought experiment

If you put some animals (both wild and domestic) on an island and left them there to roam free and we come back after a few years who would survive. In my opinion dogs would be the first to go. Although I love dogs they're too dependent on humans, it's true that stray/feral dogs can form packs and survive in the wild a regular dog like a golden retriever would get eaten by a lion instantly. Cats would be the next. They are much more independent and still behave similarly to wild cats they are still pets and rely on humans to survive. From the ones that have a good chance to survive. Would suprisngly rodents and small animals. They are quite fast and can hide in places predators can't reach like Holes, pieces of debris etc. Horses have a good chance. The main strategy for horses is organisation. Horses live in groups. So they can look out for each other. Not to mention their speed. The ones who would last until the very end would be lions , tigers bears, eagles and wolves. They have speed,size, power everything. What do you think?

Share
Sort by:
Best
Open comment sort options

Interesting. I would think horses and dogs would go first. Cats and rodents and rabbits would probably last the longest, not exactly individually but over all. Rabbits and rodents “breed like rabbits”, cats don’t feck about either…

I think they would conspire to kill any human that sets foot on the island.

u/GamerMate9000 avatar

Would really depend on environment, domestic animals might strive in certain environments,

Environment really is the key maybe certain species might form inter species packs that enabled them to survive better, possibilities are endless

u/A_Fresh_Start123 avatar

I would say Pigeons have a good chance of survival as they can survive in both urban and wild areas as they're very adaptable the biggest hurdle for them would be escaping from Raptors

Plus they can fly at like 80/90mph. They're fast.

More replies